The Great Diaper Dilemma 2009
So you have to make a choice. Sure, most us don’t want to destroy the planet by clogging landfills with disposable diapers. And there are choices to be had. But among the dizzying array is a distinct lack of convenience, ease of use and comfort. Here is my experience with ecologically friendly diaper alternative, and one not so friendly. All of the diapers pictured below are new, unused...just thought I’d mention. Of course, there is always the diaperless solution, but how many of us can reliably predict their infant’s cues and make it to the nearest toilet, bucket or shrub? Realistically any method you choose still leaves you with a mess to clean.
Cloth diapers:

Chinese prefold cloth diapers before and after washing
Personally I find using prefolds is like trying to swim upstream. They just aren’t convenient. They’re huge, bulky and don’t do anything to keep baby’s skin dry. You’ve got to carry the dirty ones and having to rinse them before washing is a real killjoy. I’ve also noticed after one washing a smooth pre-fold becomes a wrinkly prune of a diaper, see before and after photo above.. Chinese pre-folds are typically the norm for cloth diapers these days.( A pre-fold consists of a sheet of thick cotton fabric folded over and sewn shut with a cotton insert sewn down the center for absorption.)
Disposables:

Nature Boy & Girl, 7th Generation, Pamper's Swaddlers
Nature Boy & Girl diapers:
Undersized! I ordered a case of mediums for my 18 lb. infant. Mediums are supposed to fit up to 24 lbs. They did not. There is simply not enough diaper to close around my infants hips. The velcro-type center tab is too short as well. I found the outer cover of these diaper odd and thin with very little breathability for baby’s skin. There is also an aqua insert in the crotch for liquid absorption but the smell of the insert is unpleasant. When I emailed the company about the poor sizing and, lo and behold, all my emails bounced. When I called the company the answering machine stated some other company’s name. I wish I’d known before ordering that this company had gone out of business in 2004 and has been taken over by some other investors. Made up of a compostable GMO-free cornstarch cover; absorbent mix of SAP and chlorine-free wood pulp $15.99/pack of 48, or $49 for a case. Boo, hiss on customer service.
7th Generation diapers:
Ok, we like the idea of a biodegradable diaper. Though not as biodegrable as we like (Nature Boy & Girl is better), 7th Generation makes a decent diaper. But we still had leaks with big blow-outs (you know what I mean) and overnights. The tabs were also very sharp on baby’s skin because the material is a little stiff. And also, blah! on color and design. Made from an absorbent mix of SAP and chlorine-free wood pulp $51.89/pack of 88.
Pampers Swaddlers:
Ok, these diapers work for me on most levels except their huge environmental impact. They are easily packed into a diaper bag and they mostly fit baby though some big blowouts will leak up the infant’s back because there is no elastic gathering there. They smell nice and they have cute illustrations, are soft and comfortable for baby. So why do I feel guilty using them? Because they do not ever break down in airtight landfills. The absorbent gel core is the source of controversy since it was removed from tampons for causing toxic shock syndrome. It has been linked to an increase in childhood asthma and elevated testicular temperatures for boy babies which is not good.
Hybrid diaper: This type of diaper requires more work because all or some part of it is non-disposable.
G-Diaper:
A couple this bother me about this otherwise good diaper. First of all, this diaper has too many parts. 1)A cloth cover, 2)a removable waterproof 100% nylon liner, and 3) a compostable GMO-free cornstarch insert (absorbent mix of SAP and chlorine-free wood pulp). That said, if you forgo tearing out the center of the soiled insert (ick!) to break it down in the toilet with the accompanying pooh stick and instead just toss the insert into the trash (hopefully into a biodegrabable plastic garbage bag), it saves a step. Another issue, G-Diaper proclaims it is 100% plastic free. Yeah, nope. The liner is 100% nylon. Um, breathability? Additionally, the snaps that hold the liner to the cloth cover are 100% plastic and have 100% contact with baby’s skin. The third issue: staining of nylon liner. Even though the insert pad is oversized it is a flat rectangle with no contours and bunching is inevitable, with gaps leading to leaks. The cloth cover can go a few uses if dry before washing in a machine. The nylon waterproof liner cannot be put in the washer and requires your precious time and effort to clean when soiled or wet. What a bother! The nylon liner picks up stains easily and very nearly permanently. Finally, the velcro on the cloth cover is sharp and a little difficult to position to keep off baby’s skin. (G-Diapers are Swedish Society for Nature Conservation-certified) $15.99/pack of 48 at Wholefoods.

3(!) part G-Diaper system
Bum Genius:
All cloth, one piece, all washable diaper! This is an adjustable size, single hybrid diaper system with an absorbant sewn in doubled cloth insert, and a cloth water resistant exterior with all edges elasticized. Bum Genius makes an organic diaper available 12 in different cute pastel colors and white. A dozen costs us around $125. To hack this diaper for better dryness performance especially overnight I also bought some Bio-soft disposable diaper liners that made cleanup from blowouts far easier. I love this diaper except that it is very bulky and the cloth cover is so tightly gathered in the back over the elastic that it cuts into baby’s skin, and velcro can be irritating if it isn’t fastened just right.

Bum Genius Organic Diaper with adjustable size snaps
The winner? Not by a landslide but I would recommend Bum Genius with Bio-soft liners for blowouts and wetness protection. G-Diapers are a good second choice for comfort and wetness protection for those who cannot wash diapers daily and promise to buy biodegradable garbage bags(!)s or use the accompanying pooh stick to break down the insert in the toilet. 7th Generation is third for biodegradability, comfort, fit, leaks and ease of use. 7th Generation also makes one of least toxic diaper wipes and are widely available in stores.













Today the Discovery Channel aired an episode of “How It’s Made” covering the topic of chicks. A midwest commercial hatchery reveals how it “raises” (in no sense of the word) chicks from fertilized eggs for meat or egg production. Odd. The show had never ventured into realm of Living Product before. It begins with thousands of fertilized (how, they never said) eggs hermetically sealed in a chamber with automatic heat and humidity. Each egg rested on a metal prongs which rotated and tipped the egg at intervals to a 45 degree angle. This was supposed to simulate the way a mother hen turns her eggs. But the gears were not gentle. Thousands eggs turned and rotated on the metal prongs like a Pachinko game.

